PTAB REJECTS IPR PETITION AGAINST HAMILTON IP LAW CLIENT, GENESIS III
Originally Released: February 24, 2015
HAMILTON IP LAW successfully defended U.S. Patent No. 7,140,569 (’569 Patent) against a challenge to the validity of its claims via an inter partes review (IPR) proceeding before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
The patent, owned by Genesis III, Inc., covers forged hammers used in grain and feed material milling and grinding systems. The ’569 Patent has been successfully asserted previously in various litigation cases against other manufacturers including Jacobs Corporation and Black Diamond.
HAMILTON IP LAW opposed the institution of the IPR against Genesis III's '569 Patent. On January 22, 2015, in Jacobs Corporation v. Genesis III, Inc. the PTAB denied the IPR petition in all respects, finding that it failed to demonstrate a reasonable likelihood that any of the challenged claims would be held invalid under any of several proposed theories.
HAMILTON IP LAW managing partner and co-counsel for this matter, Jay R. Hamilton, noted the following:
Contrary to what patent infringers may believe, the USPTO’s post-grant proceedings do not allow infringers to act with impunity against the exclusive rights enjoyed by a patent owner. This decision denying the trial demonstrates that patent challenges at the USPTO can be defeated before expenses become crippling. The PTAB's decision has strengthened the ’569 Patent, recognizing the validity of all the patent claims in view of the three different proposed grounds of invalidity.
Mr. Hamilton, Hamilton IP Law partner Charles A. Damschen, and attorney Alexander JSW Johnson collaborated on this effort. Mr. Max Petersen and Kevin Erickson, partners at Pauley, Petersen and Erickson in Hoffman Estates, Illinois served as special counsel to Hamilton IP Law. The victory comes amid the firm’s active momentum in cases before the PTAB; Hamilton IP Law filed an ex parte challenge of validity against U.S. Pat. No. 7,942,616 on behalf of its client, Karma, Inc., in proceeding No. 90/012,666 against Allied Machine & Engineering Corporation. Allied’s ’616 patent is the subject of ongoing litigation which is presently stayed due to Allied’s appeal from the PTAB’s decision invalidating all claims of the ’616 patent.
Jay R. Hamilton, Managing Partner
HAMILTON IP LAW
Press Release – Local Iowa Inventor Honored
The Iowa Intellectual Property Law Association (IIPLA) named Wapello, Iowa native Neil Hoehle 2010 Iowa Inventor of the Year at a ceremony held Friday, October 15. This award is given to Iowa inventors who make the most significant contributions to improving the way of life for Iowans and mankind through their inventions. Mr. Hoehle is recognized for his development of a pressure balanced shaft seal assembly.
Jay R. Hamilton and Charles A. Damschen, Patent Attorneys with Hamilton IP Law, PC introduced Mr. Hoehle at the IIPLA’s awards banquet with a presentation on the background of Inpro/Seal, the inventor and the invention. “Each year many new and important inventions, both commercial and industrial, are created and patented by Iowans.
To receive this distinction from IIPLA is truly an honor,” expressed Mr. Hoehle and then added, “As a native-born Iowan, to be singled out as having created the most significant invention of the year by my home state is quite special.”
Mr. Hoehle attended the University of Iowa and received his bachelor’s degree from Western Illinois University and an MBA from the University of Iowa. He began his career as an intern at Inpro/Seal in 1981 and is currently Director of Sales & Engineering. He is a co-inventor on numerous patents and patent applications. Mr. Hoehle explains, “This product conserves energy, increases reliability and reduces environmental contamination for our industrial customers, including many here in Iowa. Though it is an industrial product, it is one of those cogs in the economic wheel that keeps things working. It helps preserve our Iowa manufacturing base by keeping our companies competitive.
Founded by Jay R. Hamilton in 2003 in Davenport, IA, Hamilton IP Law, PC serves clients specializing in a wide array of technological fields. Hamilton IP Law, PC provides counsel to various clients, from individual inventors to medium-sized businesses. More information related to Hamilton IP Law, PC can be found at www.hamiltoniplaw.com.
FOR MORE INFORMATION:
Media Contact: Natalie Linville-Mass
“…Many new and important inventions…are created and patented by Iowans. To receive this distinction from IIPLA is truly an honor.”
– Mr. Hoehle (Iowa native)